A Kenora resident is calling out some individuals running in Kenora’s 2026 municipal election, and calling on the candidates to make their positions clear on whether or not to return Anicinabe Park to three area First Nations.

Tania Cameron, an Indigenous activist with close ties to the community, took to social media earlier in the month to argue the incoming council could play a significant role in deciding whether the city continues fighting the claim in court.

Cameron first issued an open letter asking candidates to outline their views on the park, reconciliation, Indigenous economic partnerships, policing and the social issues facing Kenora.

Since then, subsequent posts made on social media by her and others have called the positions of several electoral candidates, primarily Karla Treadway, into question.

On Sept. 16, Grand Council Treaty #3 Grand Chief Francis Kavanaugh also postured on the matter, saying in a news release that “it is my belief that respecting the human dignity of our people or the rights and jurisdiction of the Anishinaabe Nation in Treaty #3 is not up for debate in a political platform.”

Speaking with the Miner and News, Cameron — a member of Niisaachewan Anishinaabe Nation who lives in Kenora — said her concerns go beyond any single campaign issue. She wants a council that understands Kenora’s history, respects the role Indigenous people play in the community and views leadership as an act of service.

“In my cultural teachings, we’re taught that when people aspire to a place of leadership, it’s to serve the community,” she said. “It’s not to be the boss or be the head person. It’s to be of service to the whole community.”

That belief prompted her to look more closely at the people seeking seats at the council table.

“I’m just writing as a citizen of Kenora, a resident of Kenora who will participate in the vote, but I need to know who I’m voting for,” Cameron said.

Cameron said she began paying closer attention to the campaign after friends raised concerns on social media about views expressed by Treadway in the past on a podcast.

Treadway, along with Tyler Johnson and Chris McCaffrey, say they are running together as a bloc under the banner “A New Vision for Kenora.”

Cameron has described some of Treadway’s statements about residential schools as denialism. She has also raised concerns about Johnson and McCaffrey campaigning alongside Treadway.

“The views expressed on one candidate’s own podcast alarmed me, and I had to look into it,” Cameron said.

In a video shared on social media by Treadway on Sept. 15, partially titled “Addressing the controversy,” Treadway framed the allegations against her as “serious mischaracterization” because she interviewed “Tim Thielmann and allowed him to challenge aspects of Canada’s reconciliation framework” on her podcast.

“I reject those characterizations completely. I have never denied that residential schools existed, I have never denied that children suffered horrific abuse inside of them, I have never argued that First Nations people do not deserve justice when governments have wronged them,” Treadway said.

“What I am willing to question, though, is whether every institution, policy and system built around reconciliation is actually producing reconciliation, because those are two very different things. You see, my work has consistently focused on corruption, institutional failure and the gap between good intentions and actual outcomes.

“There is no race or religion or institution that I haven’t touched on. I have thousands of hours of podcasts, and you’re probably going to find something in there that you disagree with, or that you don’t like, and yes, I will investigate institutions and systems operating in the name of Indigenous reconciliation too, because First Nations people do not benefit when an entire area of public policy is treated as though it’s beyond scrutiny, and at the end of the day, I want the best outcomes possible for all people.”

Thielmann, Treadway’s podcast guest in question, is the director of the 2025 film Making a Killing: Reconciliation, Genocide and the Plunder of Canada, which, according to IMDB, documents “the taking of wealth, land, and power from the Canadian public to benefit indigenous tribes.”

Among the many comments being cited from Treadway’s past podcast episode appearances are remarks framing the First Nations around Kenora as dangerous, and that Kenora’s downtown area “became Skid Row so, so fast” after a new homeless shelter was opened. In a June 9, 2026 podcast episode titled “Indian Chiefs and Liberal Corruption,” she also referred to some unnamed First Nation communities as “corrupt inside and out.”

In response to a critic on the “A New Vision for Kenora” Facebook page, when asked about his associations, as well as his former ties to Canada’s federal Liberals, Johnson responded, “Karla is a media personality, and she has opinions, so what?”

The Miner & News has reached out to Treadway, Johnson and McCaffrey for further comment.

Cameron, meanwhile, said she believes Johnson and McCaffrey’s decision to campaign with Treadway signals their support for her views.

“If they hold those kinds of views and they think that they will bring a new vision for Kenora, and they’re running that as a campaign slogan, it is not a new vision,” she said. “It’s actually taking a step back in time, where anti-Indigenous hate was rampant in our community.”

Cameron said Kenora has made slow but steady progress toward reconciliation, and she does not want to see that work reversed.

“The work has been slow. The progress has been slow, but it’s been steady, and it’s progressing,” she said.

Cameron does not plan to support Treadway, Johnson or McCaffrey but is waiting to see how the other council candidates respond to the four questions in her letter.

“I want to know, who are these individuals? What values do they have?” she said. “Are they values that will build up our community, or are they values that are going to take us a step back?”

At the centre of the letter is the future of Anicinabe Park, which the City of Kenora owns and operates but is the subject of an ongoing lawsuit.

Niisaachewan Anishinaabe Nation, Wauzhushk Onigum Nation and Washagamis Bay First Nation filed a joint claim against the City of Kenora and the federal government in 2024. They are seeking the return of the park lands and other remedies.

The First Nations allege the federal government improperly sold the former reserve land to the town in 1959 without a valid surrender and that the city participated in their dispossession. The allegations have not been proven at trial.

In July 2025, an Ontario Superior Court judge dismissed separate attempts by the city and federal government to have the claim thrown out because of the amount of time that had passed. The decision allowed the First Nations to proceed with the case but did not rule on the merits of the claim.

Cameron believes the lawsuit makes the park a legitimate election issue because the incoming council will oversee the city’s involvement in the case and could consider negotiating a resolution.

“I want to see where they stand on reconciliation,” she said. “I want to see if they would be prepared to return the land to the First Nations.”

Cameron would prefer the city to pursue a negotiated settlement rather than take the case to trial.

“Yeah, that’s what I would prefer,” she said. “It’s going to save taxpayers a lot of money.”

She added she had previously asked how much the city has spent on the case but has not received an answer. With Kenora facing infrastructure needs and other financial pressures, she questions whether continuing the legal fight is the best use of public money.

“We can’t afford it,” Cameron said. “We’ve got infrastructure issues in the city. That’s where the money should be going.”

Returning the park would also turn the city’s stated commitment to reconciliation into concrete action, she said.

The City of Kenora’s land acknowledgement recognizes that the city was originally part of the land base of one collective First Nation community that was later separated into Wauzhushk Onigum, Niisaachewan and Washagamis Bay First Nations. It also states that Kenora’s economy benefits greatly from the Anishinaabe and Métis people living in and around the city.

“If the city has a statement about reconciliation and recognizing the history of the lands, nothing says reconciliation more than the act of returning the land to the original people of the land,” Cameron said.

“I believe that would be a huge action, a huge step towards reconciliation.”

Cameron stressed that she is speaking only for herself. She is not involved in the litigation and cannot say what a transfer of ownership or control would involve.

“I do not have a say in leadership decisions,” she said. “I’m not part of the litigation process.”

She nevertheless believes returning the property would be a powerful acknowledgement of the past.

“I think the action of returning the land is very powerful, and it’s right,” Cameron said. “It’s the morally right thing to do.”

Anicinabe Park was the site of a 38-day occupation led by Louis Cameron and the Ojibway Warriors Society in 1974.

What began as a youth conference grew into a protest over discrimination, police treatment, inadequate housing, unemployment and other conditions facing Indigenous people in Kenora and surrounding communities.

Tania Cameron said the occupation and the Kenora Indian March held earlier that year remain important parts of the city’s shared history.

Her open letter also emphasizes the importance of First Nations people, governments, organizations and businesses to Kenora’s economy.

Cameron listed surrounding First Nations whose members conduct business in the city, along with Indigenous organizations that own property, lease commercial space and employ people in Kenora.

“Indigenous people own properties, we lease commercial space, we contribute to the tax base, we employ large workforces, and we spend heavily in the local economy,” she said.

“Again, the Indigenous dollar drives the local economy.”

Her second question asks candidates whether they would support economic partnerships with First Nations and the establishment of an urban reserve within Kenora.

Cameron believes an urban reserve could attract businesses and generate additional economic activity. She suggested it could potentially be established on Tunnel Island or another suitable property, although its location and structure would require further discussion.

“I thought it would be amazing to have an urban reserve in Kenora,” she said. “In my opinion, it would support the economy in Kenora because we’re able to bring other businesses into that urban reserve.”

Policing and its cost to taxpayers form the third part of Cameron’s letter.

She wants candidates to make clear whether they support Kenora continuing to receive policing services from the Ontario Provincial Police or favour re-establishing a municipal police force.

Cameron is concerned about what a return to municipal policing could cost and how it could affect property taxes.

“As a taxpayer, I do not want to see my taxes jump,” she said. “It already hurts every year to see my property taxes go up a little bit, a little bit, a little bit.”

She said the city has already commissioned a study on policing and believes remaining with the OPP makes more financial sense than creating another municipal force.

“It would be a financial hardship on the city to go back to having our own police force,” Cameron said. “I just wanted to know their stance on staying with the OPP or having our own municipal police force.”

Her final question focuses on the mental-health and social challenges facing Kenora.

Cameron wants candidates to look beyond enforcement and explain how they would address the conditions contributing to those problems.

“What are the root causes of some of the mental-health issues that we have in our community, the social issues that we have in our community, and what are they proposing to address those issues?” she said.

A few candidates have contacted Cameron to say they are preparing responses to her questions.

She plans to make their answers public, although she has not decided whether she will post them in a chart, prepare a summary of each response or publicly endorse particular candidates.

“I’ll hopefully receive a good number of candidates’ replies,” she said. “I’m going to be very thoughtful in terms of which candidates I decide to vote for.”

A candidate who declines to take a position on the park because the matter remains before the courts would be unlikely to receive her support.

“I need candidates to be bold in their views,” Cameron said.

She is also urging Indigenous residents and other voters who support reconciliation to ensure they are registered and participate in the election.

“I hadn’t planned on doing a Rock the Vote campaign here, but it sounds like it’s going to get started,” she said. “We’ve got to raise the issue. We’ve got to help people get registered to vote.”

Cameron said she is prepared to speak out when she believes a campaign could harm the community.

“I’ll be brave, I’ll be bold, and I’ll stand up against what they are representing,” she said.

“I want to have leaders elected to that office who seek to build community, who want to strengthen our community. Those are the people I will support.

By Pam Fedack, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter

Original Published on Sep 16, 2026 at 12:31

 

This item reprinted with permission from   Kenora Miner and News   Kenora, Ontario

Comments are Welcome - Leave a reply below - Posts are moderated