The two deputy ministers of education appeared before the legislature’s public accounts committee on Thursday.
They were peppered with questions about the auditor general’s report from June, which showed that the province’s students didn’t meet a single literacy assessment target from July 2022 to June 2025.
The Liberal government has decided lowering the bar is part of the solution. Instead of maintaining a target of having 90 per cent of students passing the provincial literacy test that’s given once a year, it now wants to see steady improvements.
It has set a target of anglophone schools raising their overall scores between 1.1 and 1.2 percentage points every year and francophone schools raising them two percentage points, with the goal of eventually having at least 70 to 80 per cent of students pass the test.
Ryan Donaghy, in charge of anglophone schools, defended the lower expectations, spelled out in the new 12-year education plan, as being more realistic.
“Everyone wants to be at 90 per cent plus in achievement, but we have to take into account where we actually are,” he told the politicians from every party. “We need all schools to improve.”
The deputy minister said the focus would now be on improving the outcomes school by school, rather than just pushing for better results district-wide.
He warned there was a wide range of results by school, and that interventions would now be targeted to help those with the worst scores.
“We’re developing an intervention framework,” Donaghy said. “We want a more standardized process for following up.”
The deputy minister also said academic support workers who help struggling students had been added back into the system in recent years after they were chopped more than a decade ago. But he said it could take years to see positive results in test scores, as students do them only at certain grade levels.
Looking back, the auditor general’s report showed New Brunswick students weren’t faring well. Canada-wide, New Brunswick students at the age of 15 showed the worst results the last time they were marked against their Canadian peers in an international reading assessment in 2022.
Only 72 per cent of those New Brunswick students reached an acceptable reading level, compared to 82 per cent across Canada. New Brunswick had the lowest outcome among the 10 provinces.
Ian Lee, the Progressive Conservative education critic who worked as a teacher for about 20 years, questioned whether the Liberals were doing enough to ensure student success.
“We’ve had librarians cut, not once, but twice,” he told reporters during a break. “We’ve had PD pilot project days that are being put in with no data. We’ve had the lowering of assessments. So, for me, I’m concerned, because what you’re doing to the students of New Brunswick is what you’re doing to New Brunswick as a whole.”
The Liberals, however, increased spending in the Department of Education and Early Childhood Development in the spring budget.
This year, the department is expected to spend $2.2 billion, a sizable, $119-million hike from the previous year. That’s a 7.6 per cent jump.
Asked whether the provincial government should spend even more to improve student results, Lee balked.
The Holt government is projecting that it will spend far more money than it is taking in.
“I always think that students are a priority, but at the same time, what are we at, a $1.6-billion deficit? That is a concern. So, for me, if the money has been allocated to the school districts, I would think that the districts would need to be utilizing that money the best way that they could.”
A better way to spend money, he said, would be to ensure enough supports are in the system. The auditor general had noted there was funding for one educational support teacher for every 180 students in the anglophone sector and one-to-140 ratio in the francophone sector.
And yet, departmental experts had recommended that there should be one educational support teacher for every 120 students.
“We’re a ways off,” Lee said.
Megan Mitton, the MLA from the small opposition Green party who will soon be installed as its leader, zeroed in on the lack of school psychologists.
She asked if there was still a significant shortage of the personnel, and Donaghy replied there were 40 vacancies out of 45 positions in the anglophone sector.
But he said struggling students were getting help in the meantime, even if they didn’t have a diagnosis of their particular issues, with educational assistants assigned to them.
Mitton feared too many children were falling through the cracks.
“Psychoeducational evaluations can help to diagnose things like ADHD, dyslexia, and help determine what type of support they need. And unfortunately, there are students who may wait years to get access to this.”
She said it was also unfair to expect parents, some of whom might not have the means, to pay thousands of dollars out of pocket to hire a private psychologist to do the work that should be taking place in the public school system.
“Students may need medication, and that could help improve symptoms and help with their learning,” Mitton said. “If they need to wait a couple more years to be evaluated, they may be entering middle school before they even have a diagnosis, and can have the appropriate tools to learn, and they have lost years of building that foundational learning, in literacy, in numeracy, for example.”
By John Chilibeck, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter
Original Published on Oct 10, 2026 at 07:28
Recent Comments