After years of stalled plans, public pushback, and repeated attempts to make the former Canadian National (CN) spur line work as a trail connection, the Council of the Town of Greater Napanee is now preparing to abandon that approach — pivoting to a new route while moving ahead with the sale of the rail corridor lands north of Highway 401.

A series of staff reports heading to Council’s meeting on Tuesday, Apr. 28, 2026, recommends confirming a “northern route” along Goodyear Road as the preferred connection toward the Cataraqui Trail, while also approving the sale of approximately nine acres of former CN spur line land for $100,000.

The Town’s Chief Administrative Officer (CAO), Matthew Grant, told the media on Thursday, Apr. 23, 2026, that the recommendations reflect the culmination of years of work by the Town’s Ad Hoc Trails Committee — and a shift toward options that can realistically be delivered.

“We have a mandate to build this thing,” Grant said, noting the Town has already adopted the committee’s recommendations as its policy direction. “The in-town trails they recommended are in the budget… and fall 2026 is when we’re going to construct them.”

Rail corridor no longer part of the plan

The CN rail bed, which currently crosses Highway 401 via a long abandoned, now closed-off bridge. Photo by Michelle Dorey Forestell/Kingstonist.

At the centre of the proposed shift is a clear break from a long-standing question on whether the CN spur line could serve as the backbone of a northern trail connection to the Cataraqui Trail.

Grant said that was not the direction ultimately recommended by the committee tasked with studying the issue.

“There’s a lot of discussion in the community about ‘Why don’t we use the spur line?’,” he said. “Those aren’t the recommendations we received.”

Instead, the committee — made up of both landowners and trail advocates — recommended against using the rail corridor and advised Council to explore alternative routes.

Town staff are now recommending a route along Goodyear Road, north of Highway 401, describing it as a more achievable option that still requires negotiation with property owners but presents fewer barriers.

“No matter which way you go, you’re going to have to negotiate with landowners,” Grant said. “That one was an easier path, as it turns out.”

The recommendation also includes identifying a trailhead north of Highway 401, a move Grant said could allow the Town to move forward more quickly while longer-term connections are still being developed.

“A trailhead would allow us to move quicker,” he said. “It’s clear to us people want to use it.”

Land sale tied to long-term trail goals

Alongside the route change, Council is being asked to approve the sale of the former CN spur line lands east of Highway 401 to Millspring Farms Inc. for $100,000, following a process required under the Town’s land sale bylaw.

Michael Nobes the Town’s General Manager of Growth & Infrastructure, noted that the lands were previously declared surplus and offered to abutting landowners, with Millspring Farms the only party to express interest.

As part of the same transaction, the Town would acquire a 10-metre-wide strip of Millspring’s land along Goodyear Road — roughly 2.2 acres — to support the future trail route.

The deal includes a key condition: the Town would have up to 15 years to either construct or begin constructing a trail connection as part of a broader network. If that does not happen, the buyer would have the option to buy the land back at the original price.

“If the Town does nothing within 15 years, Millspring can repurchase it,” Nobes explained, adding that the condition ensures the land remains tied to the municipality’s long-term trail objectives.

Financially, the transaction is expected to result in a net gain for the Town after accounting for the land purchase, survey costs, and legal fees.

Millspring Farms owner Dave Milligan told Kingstonist late Thursday that the deal was not the farm’s preferred outcome, but ultimately reflects a good compromise.

“We didn’t want to give up any land, but the Town was pushing for ownership instead of an agreement,” Milligan said in an interview. “At a certain point, it becomes a question of protecting the farm and getting some certainty, so we made the compromise.”

Milligan said limiting public access to the former rail bed was a key factor in the decision.

“Not having this access point, being the old rail bed… that allows us to carry on for future generations farming here,” he said.

In-town trail construction planned for 2026

While the northern route remains a longer-term goal, staff say the Town is ready to move ahead with construction of an in-town trail network beginning in 2026.

Chris Brown, Director of Parks, Recreation & Culture, said the committee’s recommended “Plan A” will be implemented in phases, starting with a loop connecting County Road 1 and Church Street through Riverside Cemetery, before extending north toward the Highway 401 corridor.

“The committee’s approach is to advance trail development by completing Plan A,” Brown said. “We planned for that work to be done in 2026.”

To support construction, staff are recommending the removal of rails along the in-town portion of the former CN line, a step Brown said is necessary to allow municipal equipment to properly prepare the trail surface.

While scrap steel from the rails will generate some revenue, updated estimates show removal will result in a net cost to the Town — roughly $4,000 for the in-town section — due to declining commodity prices.

“We were hoping it would be neutral,” Brown said, “but it is going to cost us.”

Broader estimates show similar shortfalls for removing the full rail segment, with steel prices having dropped significantly since 2021.

Despite that, staff are recommending proceeding with removal where necessary to enable construction, rather than delaying the project in hopes of improved market conditions.

The in-town trail project is included in the 2026 capital budget, with approximately $70,000 allocated for external costs and additional work to be completed using in-house staff and equipment.

Implementation is expected to begin in fall 2026, once seasonal capital projects are complete.

A long-running file reaches a turning point

The decisions now before Council mark a significant shift in a process that has unfolded over more than a decade — and intensified in recent years as Council sought a viable path forward.

The CN spur line was first closed in 2009, with the Town acquiring the corridor in 2012. Since then, multiple approaches have been explored, including trail development along the rail line, scrap removal, and eventual sale.

In 2023, following public input and concerns from neighbouring landowners, Council established the Ad Hoc Trails Committee to reassess the project. The group met more than 20 times over two years before delivering its recommendations.

“We’re not starting from scratch,” Grant emphasized. “This is based on recommendations that we’ve received.”

Those recommendations — and the staff reports now before Council — signal a shift away from a contested and uncertain rail corridor plan toward a phased approach focused on what can be built in the near term.

By Michelle Dorey Forestell, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter

Original Published on Apr 27, 2026 at 07:30

This item reprinted with permission from   Kingstonist   Kingston, Ontario

Comments are Welcome - Leave a reply below - Posts are moderated