The amendment reversed a staff recommendation and previous council decision to allow a 20-metre standard on six specific lakes (Ril Lake, Paint Lake, Echo Lake, Grand View Lake, Dicki Lake, and Real Lake). The change came after the Lake of Bays Association presented science-backed evidence that 30 metres is the minimum needed to protect fish habitat and filter sediment runoff.
On Tuesday, Aug. 25 during a planning matters council meeting, Coun. George Anderson framed it simply: “Development is permanent. In an ideal world, all builds would be 30 metres from the water. That’s not possible in our situation, but science states that we should aspire to that standard.”
The timing of the vote coincided with multiple waterfront applications during the council meeting, illustrating the immediate impact of the new plan.
What changes does the new official plan bring to Lake of Bays?
The new official plan, the township’s first comprehensive rewrite since 1999, sets the land-use framework for the next 25 years.
Alongside the 30-metre shoreline setback, the new official plan has made three other notable changes.
Regarding rural lot sizes, the plan maintains a four-hectare (roughly 10-acre) minimum for new rural residential lots in areas outside hamlet boundaries.
Staff noted the bylaw allows reductions to one hectare on a case-by-case basis, but that requires a planning application process.
The plan also incorporated site-specific policies for the Limberlost Forest and Wildlife Reserve area, which council had approved at a previous meeting.
The plan also clarifies the township’s natural heritage policies, recognizing Lake of Bays’ ecological connectivity while aligning with the District Municipality of Muskoka’s system. Staff said the change addresses district concerns while maintaining township objectives.
How will new shoreline setbacks affect planning applications?
Christine Jeffrey, a neighbour on Pine Ridge Road, came to council to oppose an application by Ann and Timothy O’Connor to rebuild a deteriorating boat house with a significant height increase from 5.4 metres to 8.2 metres — a 50 per cent jump.
Jeffrey raised concerns about the height of the boat house, adding she recently built a new boat house on her property and “had to meet all the requirements.” The concerned neighbour added they appreciate the planning requirements and enjoy the “character of the lake that we’ve been on for three generations now.”
Additionally, Jeffrey questioned whether the rebuild actually qualifies as “nonconforming” (allowed to stay the same) or constitutes a new structure that should comply with current rules.
The existing dwelling, Jeffrey explained, only encroaches past the required 20-metre setback in one tiny corner. But the proposed new dwelling would encroach in multiple places — expanding the footprint into the setback zone.
“If we’re creating a whole new footprint, why isn’t this building moving back to meet that 20-metre setback?” Jeffrey asked.
Despite the applicant’s agent defending the structure’s conditions, council sided with Jeffrey.
Coun. Rick Brooks called the boat house height “excessive” and “contradictory to our vision.”
The application was denied. The decision reflects the township’s updated approach to waterfront development, which includes stricter setback requirements and greater consideration of existing planning regulations.
How will the official plan’s regulations affect accessibility?
Joel Dimitry, 80, sought to formalize waterfront structures — sheds, docks, pergola, deck — that have existed on his Sawmill Lane property for up to 20 years without permits. The structures violate multiple bylaw requirements: the lot is over-coverage, and the sheds and deck are too close to the side property lines.
Dimitry explained he bought the property bare in 1983, built a cottage, and modified it as his family grew. In 2004, ice destroyed the boathouse. He replaced it with floating docks, thinking they didn’t need permits. Two sheds followed around the same time. The pergola came later — his solution to sun damage after 26 basal cell carcinomas and two squamous cell carcinomas removed from his skin.
“I have made it a point to keep the waterfront green,” Dimitry said, describing plantings of pine, hydrangea, lilies, daisies, and blue spruce. “I use no fertilizer or insecticides on my property, so nothing flows into the lake. I have planted more than 100 trees on my property.”
Three neighbours submitted letters of support, saying the structures don’t affect them and have been there for years.
Dimitry continued to explain that he and his wife Judy, 79, are both disabled and have mobility issues. The two Sawmill Lane residents want to add a small deck ramp at the back of the dwelling to make it easier to bring in groceries and manage daily life.
“Most people at 80 sell their cottages and move back to the city,” Dimitry said. “All of my neighbours have. Well, we love Muskoka. We wanted to make it our home and live easier because of our physical disabilities.”
The couple’s request called for a full-review of the property’s noncompliance.
Staff recommended denial. But Coun. Brooks made an explicit call: “Do not delete the ramp. I think that is a necessity.”
Council deferred the application to Oct. 13, giving Dimitry time to revise the proposal and work with staff on reducing lot coverage, possibly shrinking the pergola, and adding a planting plan.
The case raises questions about how existing planning requirements will apply to accessibility improvements on waterfront properties as the township implements its new official plan.
Council debates regulations and growth in the township
Though council was in favour of increasing shoreline setbacks, discussion turned to Lake of Bays’ wider planning regulations and how they affect growth and housing.
Coun. Brooks voiced frustration the township talks about growth but keeps boundaries tight and rural lot minimums large – roughly 10-acres in some areas.
“We’re not promoting growth,” he said. “We’re not expanding boundaries. We say we can make smaller homes, but we have to have 10-acre lots. There’s a contradictory there.”
Coun. Lacroix raised a similar point: tiny homes are encouraged, but large rural lot requirements undermine affordability.
While environmental protection remains a priority, council also discussed the balance between new regulations, housing and development.
The township is still waiting for approval of the adopted official plan by the District of Muskoka.
Rebecca Hudescu is a Local Journalism Initiative reporter writing for the Huntsville Forester. The Local Journalism Initiative is funded by the Government of Canada.
By Rebecca Hudescu, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter
Original Published on Aug 28, 2026 at 14:26
Recent Comments