
EDITOR’S NOTE: The following information comes from a meeting researcher Gillian Allen had with Membertou First Nation on Feb. 3, where she presented her draft report of the history of the community. Her research will be a key factor in a specific claim to be filed against the federal government later this year based on administrative abuse and negligence. Part 1 of this article featured the Kings Road Reserve leading up to the establishment of Membertou. This is Part 2 and is based on Allen’s findings about the treatment of the Membertou community since 1929 and the repercussions of displacement.
The Kings Road Reserve was a community on Sydney Harbour with a documented history dating back to 1720, although it is believed the Mi’kmaq, who were a fishing and harvesting people, inhabited the shores of the Sydney area for perhaps millennia. The reserve site – which is where the Sydney Medical Arts building sits now – was ideally located for seasonal fishing and harvesting.
In 1915, Kuntewiktuk (the original name used by the Mi’kmaq) had about 120 residents, which included 27 homes and a schoolhouse. But in 1916, after decades of pressure by individuals and governments, the court of Canada ruled that relocation of the community was in the best interests of the public.
The Department of Indian Affairs purchased 65 acres of land located just outside of Sydney’s limits and up the hill from where the people lived and between 1926 and 1929, all former residents of Kuntewiktuk were relocated to what is now known as Membertou.
In June 1929, a government official instructed that an advertisement for the sale of the land the Mi’kmaq were moved from was to be placed in the local newspapers.
“We went backwards and forwards through every Sydney newspaper from June to September and there’s no
She says researchers found nothing, so they assume the land was never advertised for sale.
Allen says that from 1929 until roughly the mid-1950s, the city of Sydney had their eyes on Kings Road.
For a while, she says, it was leased as parkland, and then it became a parking lot for the 1935 celebration of Sydney’s 150th birthday.
All the time, it appears that the land was being used by others for such things as a community garden for free. And the researcher’s work has discovered that the city was after the federal government to transfer it to the city of Sydney for no cost.
“They threatened the Department of Indian Affairs with unpaid municipal taxes and threatened them with charging ‘improvement charges’ as they called it,’ Allen said.
“But the threats were just fluff because federal land doesn’t pay taxes.”
She has even found evidence that the city threatened to sell the land in a tax sale for unpaid taxes.
In 1957, Allen says, the city was still trying to get Kings Road without paying for it. At that time, it was appraised for $6,500.
The researcher says that concurrently, the province was reorganizing its vision of the Mi’kmaq nation in Nova Scotia.
“They began the process of dividing the one big Mi’kmaq band, which represents the portion of the nation here in Nova Scotia running from Meat Cove to Yarmouth.”
In 1960, by Privy Council order, 11 bands were created in Nova Scotia. The Sydney band, as it was called at the time (Membertou), was allotted land on portions of Kings Road, Lingan Road, the present site of Membertou, Caribou Marsh and other lots, as well as one-fifth interest in Malagawatch.
MEDICAL CLINIC?
By 1963, the Kings Road Reserve property came under scrutiny again from someone who wanted to buy it.
“And it’s not the City of Sydney – they’ve given up on getting the land for free,” Allen told community members.
She said it was Dr. Francis Kelly, who was also under a contract with the Department of Indian Affairs to provide medical care for the Mi’kmaq. He offered to purchase it for the previous (1957) assessment price of $6,500 from Indian Affairs.
Kelly said he was going to build a medical clinic on the land and it would be a benefit to Membertou because they would have a family doctor.
But before another appraisal could be done, the federal government set the date of December 1963 for a surrender meeting – the term for when an Indigenous Reserve turns its land over to government. The meeting and resulting vote had complicated rules that had to be followed precisely or the vote was invalid.
The first vote was invalid, so a second one was held in 1964. Through the whole process, the community was led to believe that there would be a medical clinic of benefit to them in the sale.
Membertou voted to surrender the land, however in the surrender documents, there was no mention of a medical clinic for Mi’kmaq use.
“It’s clear that the people in Ottawa and the Mi’kmaq were all working under the assumption that if they gave surrender so that Dr. Kelly could purchase the site at appraisal price of $7,500, there would be a clinic built,” Allen said.
The Governor General ended up signing the surrender even before Indian Affairs had decided if they were going to recommend it.
In 1965, Kelly began building on the property and Allen says it turned out to be a three-storey office building and not specifically a medical clinic.

RAILWAY ISSUE
In 1973, when the federal government started taking specific claims from the Indigenous population, Membertou tried filing a claim based on the railway being put on the reserve and not paid for until 17 years later.
“This is a whole new thing in 1973, this specific claim process, so Membertou says, we’ll dip a toe in and see how this is going to work,” says Allen.
But, she says, the Department of Indian Affairs determined they had no outstanding lawful obligation in relation to the rail line going through the reserve.
In 2015, using their own money, Membertou purchased that land back from its owners.
“You can look at it as where we came from here and it’s full circle, and we’re back to owning the property again,” said Membertou Chief Terry Paul in 2015 as he stood beside a glass-encased diorama of the former reserve. A stone monument now sits by the road in front of the Medical Arts Building.
In 2023, chief and council requested that Allen go back through her research materials and put together the historical documentation needed for the report for the Kings Road Reserve claim.
ADMINISTRATIVE ABUSE
It is hoped that the material can establish a pattern of administrative abuse and negligence by government. Membertou First Nation Executive Director Trevor Bernard told the Cape Breton Post in November that they hope the process will not be an adversarial one.
In answer to a question from band councillor Buster Matthews at the community meeting, Bernard said an actuary will have to determine the value of the land and the misdeeds that were committed and what type of dollar amount could be attached to the claim.
In answer to another question about if Dr. Kelly kept his promise to provide healthcare for the Mi’kmaq, and if the building he constructed could be replaced, she answered that she didn’t think he did any more than he was already required to do under his contract with Indian Affairs.
“But you have it now,” she said. You can do what you want within the confines of Sydney’s zoning, because it’s not reserve land.”
She said Membertou has gone through a very long and detailed process, and the land now falls under the First Nations land management system, which gives them more control over what they do with their lands.
“The ownership that Membertou Corporation has now is like any other owner of a land within the confines of zoning. You can do what you want.”
She said that will be a question for the community, council, and chief down the road.
Rosemary Godin is the Local Journalism Initiative reporter for the Cape Breton Post, an initiative funded by the federal government.
By Rosemary Godin, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter
Original Published on Feb 17, 2026 at 10:27
Recent Comments