A tourist tax for Norfolk County is on hold indefinitely, and the mayor of the lakeside municipality says residents will be poorer for it.

Mayor  Amy Martin blasted councillors who voted on Tuesday to defer a decision  on implementing a four per cent “municipal accommodation tax” after  approving the MAT “in principle” at a previous meeting.

“I’m extremely disappointed,” Martin said after the 5-4 vote.

“The deferral, I believe, is a ‘no’ — and this council just doesn’t have the political will to say it.”

The province allows  municipalities to add a surcharge to overnight stays at hotels, motels,  bed and breakfasts and cottages rented through platforms like Airbnb and  Vrbo.

The MAT is only  applied to the room rate, not extras like food, and it is the guests of  the accommodation who pay the tax, not local residents or business  owners.

More than 80 municipalities have started collecting a MAT since the province created the program in 2017.

Consultants hired by Norfolk estimate the  tax would bring in just over $700,000 in its first year, calling the  MAT “a strategic opportunity to generate sustainable tourism funding  without imposing an additional tax burden on residents.”

By law, at least half the MAT revenue must be given to a third-party organization to spend on destination marketing.

The balance can be spent on tourist-related infrastructure, which in  Norfolk could run the gamut from cleaning the Port Dover beach to  repairing roads and bridges that lead into Long Point.

Local critics of the MAT — including Haldimand-Norfolk MPP Bobbi Ann  Brady — argue the surcharge could keep tourists away or cause them to  reduce spending during their stay, while creating more paperwork for  business owners.

Advocates, such as Coun. Adam  Veri, point to studies saying MAT-funded marketing brings in more  tourists and helps municipalities upgrade infrastructure without leaning  on taxpayers.

“This  is the closest thing we have to supporting small business directly,”  Veri told council on Tuesday, noting the spinoff economic benefit of  drawing more visitors to Norfolk would extend beyond the tourism sector.

‘Ducks in a row’

After  council endorsed the MAT in principle on Feb. 10, the next step was to  have municipal staff present a business plan in March.

The earliest the tax would have been implemented was July 2027.

But  on Tuesday, Coun. Chris Van Paassen asked to defer the final vote on  the MAT until after council passed a bylaw to regulate unlicensed rental  properties like cottages.

Van Paassen said he also wants to see “a detailed business case” for the  MAT, including what governing body would oversee tourism promotion and  how the municipality would spend the new revenue.

“In my mind, there’s certain steps that we should take before the  implementation of the tax,” said Van Paassen, who was also skeptical the  county could oversee a new program without hiring more employees.

But Martin accused Van Paassen  of playing politics, pointing out the original motion stipulated no MAT  dollars were to be collected or spent before a governing body was  created with representation from the tourism industry, and that spending  priorities were set out in a business plan.

A short-term rental bylaw also had to be signed into law before the MAT would take effect, Martin noted.

Van Paassen argued it was worth the wait to “get our ducks in a row.”

“We’ve  been told by staff it’s real easy to throw that budget together,” he  said. “When the parts of the puzzle have been put together, then you get  to look at the whole picture.”

John  Regan, Norfolk’s director of strategic innovation and economic  development, told council putting off the MAT decision would “sidetrack”  the issue after nearly three years of public consultation that included  tourism industry stakeholders.

“There were no steps being missed,” Regan said.

Coun.  Linda Vandendriessche said she was confident municipal staff could  craft a business plan and a short-term rental bylaw, while  simultaneously laying the groundwork for the MAT.

“I think it’s silly to procrastinate,” she said.

Tourism ‘helps everything else’

Coun.  Alan Duthie said councillors in Prince Edward County told him the  decision to implement the MAT in their community was a “no-brainer,” as  the tourist tax brings in more than $2.1 million each year.

Representatives  from the Simcoe and District Chamber of Commerce, the Port Dover Board  of Trade and a consortium of local accommodation providers also endorsed  the MAT.

“There isn’t  one person employed by Norfolk County that has the word tourism in  their job title. Sad but true,” Andrew Schneider from the Erie Beach  Hotel in Port Dover said on Tuesday.

“If  we don’t move forward with this today, the data will be out of date, we  still won’t have a policy on short-term rentals and we’ll all wonder  why people aren’t visiting more often.”

Chamber of commerce treasurer Kirby Shieck said it was “almost impossible to imagine” the MAT keeping tourists away.

“Eight  dollars on a $200 overnight (hotel room) is not the difference between  people staying here and not staying here,” he said.

“You mess with tourism, it hurts. You work on tourism, it helps everything else.”

Martin said council was “waffling” instead of pledging to work together with tourism operators who have “skin in the game.”

While  initially seen in larger cities like Toronto and Hamilton, smaller  municipalities like Lambton Shores — with fewer residents than Simcoe —  also collect a MAT, Veri noted.

“The argument I’ve seen is this is not for Norfolk because it’s a big-city thing. Nonsense,” he said.

“This is a small-town solution to support tourism and growth.”

‘Dead in the water’

The  debate at town hall came against a backdrop of vociferous opposition to  the MAT from some residents commenting on social media.

Long Point business owner Ray Ferris gathered 1,600 signatures on a petition  asking council to reject the MAT and “adopt solutions that will bolster  our economic framework while nurturing tourism instead of stifling it.”

Veri warned of the danger of  making policy decisions guided by social-media comments rather than  expert advice. He said he could find no evidence that charging a tourist  tax hurts the local economy.

“We  would not defer a revenue stream for manufacturing. We certainly would  not defer a revenue stream for agriculture,” Veri said.

“I  just feel like if the public outcry and pressure wasn’t so miserable  and mean on this, we’d be having a different conversation,” he said.

Coun. Tom Masschaele  said the “long overdue” short-term rental bylaw was the main reason he  could not support moving ahead with the MAT, with Coun. Kim Huffman  saying council had been waiting “for years” for staff to craft rules  governing rental properties.

But  The Spectator confirmed no Norfolk councillor has formally tabled a  motion asking municipal staff to draft such a bylaw in the last five  years.

Duthie said he  was “perplexed” as to why councillors complaining about a missing bylaw  would vote against a plan that would spur it into being.

“Agreed,” Martin said. “Pretty hypocritical.”

The  mayor suggested the MAT’s detractors used the lack of a short-term  rental bylaw as political cover to torpedo the tourist tax.

Van Paassen pushed back, saying council could reopen the MAT debate once the bylaw passes.

“It’s not dead in the water,” he said.

But  Martin predicted councillors would find some reason to delay the bylaw  and kill the MAT at the same time, adding it would then be hard to  explain to residents saddled with a 5.5 per cent property tax increase  this year why council rejected an annual pot of free money.

“The  joke will be on council when we’re without a short-term rental policy  and a municipal accommodation tax down the road,” Martin said.

By J.P. Antonacci, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter

Original Published on Mar 02, 2026 at 07:26

This item reprinted with permission from   The Spectator   Hamilton, Ontario
Comments are Welcome - Leave a reply below - Posts are moderated