Two Ontario residents have asked the provincial government to review Atura Power’s environmental approval for the Napanee Generating Station expansion, arguing that the approval could allow key noise control measures to be delayed until 2038 while the expanded facility continues operating.
Jesse Walden and Eva Tolkin, both of Prince Edward County, filed an Application for Review earlier this month seeking changes to the Environmental Compliance Approval (ECA) that was issued by the Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks (MECP) on December 22, 2025, for the Napanee Generating Station and its planned expansion.
The Napanee Generating Station, located on Lake Ontario along Loyalist Parkway southeast of Napanee, is currently undergoing an expansion that will add a new simple-cycle natural gas turbine to the existing facility.
The application for review, signed on Friday, Jun. 5, 2026, challenges several noise-related conditions in the facility’s environmental approval, including requirements for monitoring, testing, and future noise control measures.
“The public-interest threshold under the [Environmental Bill of Rights] is plainly met,” the applicants wrote in the filing. “This is not an abstract concern about future annoyance.”
Under Ontario’s Environmental Bill of Rights, any two Ontario residents may ask the province to review an existing policy, law, regulation, or approval if they believe changes are needed to protect the environment. The ministry must then decide whether conducting a review would be in the public interest.
At the centre of the dispute is language in the approval governing a future Noise Abatement Action Plan.
The applicants say one section of the approval appears to give Atura up to 13 years to install certain physical noise control measures, while another section appears to allow the facility to rely on those future measures when demonstrating compliance with provincial noise standards.
If interpreted that way, the applicants argue, the approval could allow mitigation measures to be delayed until December 2038.
The applicants are asking the ministry to clarify that the facility must comply with provincial noise standards at all times, accelerate implementation of mitigation measures, and require additional testing and monitoring before expansion operations begin.
The application also argues that unanswered questions remain about “tonal noise” — persistent sounds such as humming, buzzing, or whining that can be more noticeable and disruptive than ordinary background noise.
According to the filing, previous acoustic studies and assessments did not fully resolve concerns about tonal noise at the facility. The applicants argue that additional receptor-specific testing was still required after the approval was issued and that uncertainty remains about whether the station can consistently meet provincial noise limits.
In practical terms, the applicants argue that nearby residents could be left waiting years for physical noise control measures intended to address ongoing concerns.
The application also argues that the noise concerns should not be viewed in isolation.
Walden and Tolkin point to the growing concentration of energy projects along the Napanee-Lennox shoreline corridor, which already hosts the Napanee and Lennox generating stations and is slated to host additional battery and compressed-air energy storage projects.
While acknowledging Ontario’s need for reliable electricity, they argue that the cumulative effects of the region’s growing energy infrastructure deserve closer scrutiny.
“The Applicants recognize Ontario’s need for a reliable electricity supply and do not ask MECP to decide energy policy through this application,” the filing states. “But the Napanee/Lennox corridor is being asked to host a concentrated buildout of major electricity infrastructure.”
The application does not seek to revoke the approval or halt the expansion project.
By Michelle Dorey Forestell, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter
Original Published on Jun 10, 2026 at 10:53
Recent Comments